Charles Tillys State Making - 1146 Words

Charles Tilly (1929-2008) is a former sociologist and political scientist who introduced the idea of state-making through state-makers in global politics. Charles Tilly argued that state-making is the process by which state-makers eliminate other hostile or adverse powerful men within a given territory. State-makers are the power holders in society such as kings or landowners . In â€Å"Bringing the State Back† (Tilly, Charles. 172) Tilly argues that states are formed through a capricious and unintentional process by which state-makers enforce war in the pursuit of territory, human population and scarce resources. Tilly says that state-makers did not take part in the pivotal and costly tasks of war-making, extraction and capital accumulation with a mind set of ultimately forming a state. Rather, Tilly argued that the pursuit of resources for war-making, capital accumulation and extraction was required to gain territory, money and human population. Tilly describes capital accum ulation as the process of investing money into warfare in return for future profits or benefits. Lastly, Tilly defines extraction as acquiring means such as population, money or weaponry to carry out the initial war-making process. Modern day rebel militant forces such as ISIS and the Taliban support Tilly’s explanation of state-making, however ISIS challenges the aspect of unintentional state-making, as it ultimately envisages the emergence of a state once the war-making is over. In early June 2014 anShow MoreRelatedThe Western Military Trajectory During The Gunpowder And First Industrial Revolutions2121 Words   |  9 Pagessome of these exploitations affected the Western military trajectory during the Gunpowder and First Industrial Revolutions, most often leaving the non-Western militaries lagging behind. It will also consider the rise of the nation-state and its conflict with non-state actors, specifically during the Information Revolution. With the French invasion of Italy in 1494, France demonstrated that the exploitation and advancement of a technology could give one side an extreme advantage over the side whichRead MoreKhmer Rouge Revolution In Cambodia Essay1470 Words   |  6 Pagesconstruct his communal agrarian utopia. The debate about the definition of revolution and the reason why revolutions happen have been vibrant in the studies of revolutions. A structural perspective focusing on states and a cultural perspective focusing on individuals are two main ways making sense of revolutions. In the case of the Khmer Rouge revolution in Cambodia, a cultural perspective does a better job explaining why people in rural areas followed Pol Pot because the interaction between Pol PotRead More The Social Construction of Workers’ Collectivism1655 Words   |  7 Pagesdifferent modes of action are situationally specific. Hence, the right question to be asked is under what conditions will workers come to acquire a sense of common interests, join a union and participate in collective action directed towards management or state? This question has more relevancy in understanding the extent and nature of union renewal as the way in which workers acquire collective definition of their interests, the greater the willingness to join and participate in collective action, the greaterRead MoreCase Studies--War Makes the State, and the State Makes War2267 Words   |  10 PagesThis essay is first concerned with the Charles Tilly’s principle around by histhe famous saying: War makes the state, and the state makes war. Meanwhile, I will explain the relationship between the state and its four activities: War Mmaking, State Mmaking, Protection, Extraction. The filiation of state and war will be illustrated later. I will use Palestine region will be used as the main case study to demonstrate this essay and I will try to use this example to explain more clearly with the relationshipRead MorePublic State Formation And Stimulation Of Increased Ethnic Conflict3180 Words   |  13 PagesMichael Snyder State Building Sovereign State Formation and Stimulation of Increased Ethnic Conflict This paper looks to examine parallels in the rise of ethnic tensions that have followed state building efforts of multiple forms in regions that had legacies of colonial rule, traditionally independent states, and newly independent states. In considering the potential for ethnic conflicts to become violent we must consider the fact that the ethnic divisions have evolved in a longer runningRead MoreTheories of Revolution2542 Words   |  11 Pagesgrowth†; and the â€Å"dislocation among the elites that traditionally mediate peasants’ interactions with government authorities and the outside world†.[1] From reading Charles Tilly’s paper â€Å"Does Modernization Breed Revolution†, there appears to be one prominent reason for revolutions – the â€Å"concentration of power in the national states†.[2] He explains that there are four conditions necessary for a revolution to begin: 1. â€Å"The appearance of contenders or coalitions of contenders, advancingRead MoreModernization: Afghanistan vs India Essay1845 Words   |  8 Pages Department of Political Science and Humanities The Final Research Paper December 4th, 2013 State Building and Political Development Kohistani ID# 8709 Professor: Isaqzadeh State Building (POL-335)-Sections One The 2013 Fall Semester Modernization in Afghanistan vs. India The political scientists, economists, philosophers, and other scientists have different views andRead MoreTheu.s. State Department Defines Terrorism1785 Words   |  8 PagesThe U.S. State Department defines terrorism, according to Piazza (2006), â€Å"premeditated, politically motivated violence perpetrated against noncombatant targets by sub national groups or clandestine agents, usually intended to influence an audience† (p. 165). Throughout history, labor disputes have often been accompanied by terror and resistance movements. Terrorism dates way back in history, but political terrorism only dates back to the last century and is regarded as a new phenomenon. For exampleRead MoreThe Movement Of The Iranian Revolution2044 Words   |  9 Pagesdisplacements inherit in the economic programs based on development models. In the economic development programs, no attention was given to the relationship between development goals and programs and the problems resulting from the current policy makings which could only be created by combining the program and policies of development and stability. Inflation was considered a short term and solvable problem but when predicaments reached a high pitch, shock therapy were applied, which was naturallyRead MoreAfrican Lost Generation Essay3468 Words   |  14 Pagesgeneration model is also concerned with the disintegration of the ‘household’ – a notional and idealised establishment that asserts gender and generational morality, harmony and control, and ensures that youth reproduce their parent’s values. In this state of crisis youths allegedly fail to reach adult status, create imaginary worlds in which they can achieve their unavailable goals (Mains:2007:661;Jones:2009:670), resort to illegal activities to support themselves and become prey to the immoral forces